How to Select a Prime Rib Roast (What You Need to Know)
Prime Rib Roast is rich, juicy and tender – a spectacular centerpiece for the holidays, especially when it’s served with Horseradish Sauce and Mashed Potatoes. Prime rib is considered the king of all beef cuts.
This post is a collaboration with Beef. It’s What’s For Dinner. on behalf of the Beef Checkoff. I received compensation, but all opinions are my own.
Prime Rib Roast is truly simple to prepare. Here is everything you need to know to purchase the perfect Prime Rib Roast, from understanding beef quality grades, selecting bone-in or boneless, and how big of a roast you need for your gathering.
This post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy.
How to Pick the Perfect Prime Roast:
A Prime Rib Roast is a true holiday show stopper and one of the most impressive pieces of meat you can make for your family or friends. Making a great Prime Rib Roast begins at the butcher counter. You need to know how to pick the perfect rib roast. When you start with such a delicious high-quality protein, the culinary possibilities are endless!
Cooks Tip: Beef. It’s What’s For Dinner. has both inspiration and all of the tips and tools that families need to prepare the perfect holiday meal. For example, Chuck Knows Beef, the only all-knowing beef virtual assistant, is the only helper that you need in the kitchen this season. Chuck can tell you exactly how to prepare that holiday roast, including how to follow the right cooking temperatures and even suggest recipes the whole family will love. Check out Chuck at ChuckKnowsBeef.com.
What is Prime Rib?
At the store, “Prime Rib Roast” can go by different names including Rib Roast, or Standing Rib Roast (because it is positioned standing on the rib bones as it roasts). It can be found in the meat case with both boneless and bone-in options. So what cut of meat is Prime Rib Roast? The Ribeye Roast comes from the rib primal which gives it the rich, beefy flavor everyone loves. It is savory, finely textured and typically has generous marbling.
Fun Fact: If you cut prime rib roast into steaks, you get ribeye steaks.
Which Grade – USDA Prime or Choice?
There are different kinds of beef grades to consider. The USDA grading is what tells you the potential tenderness and juiciness of the roast you are getting. If you are looking to splurge, get the USDA prime grade. It can be harder to find, so know what to ask for. There is also a significant price difference between USDA Prime and Choice with Prime costing a bit more.
- “USDA Prime” – top 8% of all US beef (a bit harder to find), heavy marbling that is evenly distributed.
- “USDA Choice” – moderate marbling and is a high-quality option that is available in most supermarkets.
- “Select” – value-priced, less marbling, potentially less tender and juicy.
Chuck End vs. Loin End:
Whether you are getting “USDA Prime” or “USDA Choice” grade, you can also choose whether you want it cut from the “chuck” end or from the “loin” end.
- The chuck end (pictured on left): ribs 6-9, has more fat around and between the central meat.
- The loin end (pictured on right): ribs 10-12, or the “first cut,” has less fat and a larger, leaner central eye of meat.
Bone-in or Boneless Prime Rib?
We prefer bone-in prime rib because the bone insulates the meat as it cooks and produces more flavorful and tender results, but we suggest buying the type that is called for in the recipe you are using.
The primary benefit of getting boneless is ease of carving. Ask the butcher to remove the bones and tie them back onto the roast. The ribs will still keep the meat insulated and tender and you can easily remove the string and ribs before serving.
Chef’s Tip: Keep the fat cap that is present over the top of the roast to prevent the beef from drying out while cooking. Also, since all roasts vary in size and weight, a meat-thermometer is critical for great results.
How Much Prime Rib Per Person?
As a general rule of thumb, plan for 1 rib for every 2 people. If you have a big menu, you could easily get away with serving 3 people pr bone.
- 8-10 pound bone-in Prime Rib Roast = 4-5 ribs. Serves 8-10 people or more.
- 4-6 pound bone-in Prime Rib Roast = 2 ribs. Serves 4-6 people or more.
How to Prepare a Rib Roast:
We partnered with Beef. It’s What’s For Dinner. and collaborated with several bloggers to teach you how to make the ultimate holiday feast with a Prime Rib Roast. Now that you are a pro at selecting your roast, check out the method Natalya of Mom’s Dish uses for a spice-rubbed rib roast.
More Beef Recipes for your Holiday Menu:
These are our favorite show-stopping beef recipes, from roasts to stews. Nicely done, beef. You put the seasoning in the holiday season!
- Beef Tenderloin – juicy and so easy to prepare
- Garlic Crusted Prime Rib – our top-rated roast
- Filet Mignon – in a wine cream sauce
- Beef Stew – with tender morsels of beef
- Meatloaf – with the best glaze
- Beef Stroganoff – in mushroom sauce
This post was really confusing to me because of all the pop up ads and distractions. I want to splurge this Xmas for my adult kids and their families. I know this meal will be $$ but I’m wanting to make a special dinner. Do you have a simpler post that outlines how to pick the best roast? I’ve seen your posts on how to cook… but I think starting with the best roast is essential. Sorry to complain…
Hi Marilyn! I’m sorry to hear that. You may try clearing your cache to see if that helps with the pop-ups. Also, you can view this prime rib recipe for some helpful hints and tips (read through the blog notes). Merry Christmas! I hope you are able to find what you are searching for! Enjoy.
You are my go to girl to look up any recipe. You are the best and make me feel like I am a chef and a baker. Thank you ♥️
Thank you, Liz! I’m so glad you love my recipes.
Natasha, I love your recipes and videos. I have a little cookbook started for my grandchildren and it’s getting filled with your recipes that we share at our table so often. Your are a great cook and a delight to watch!
That is a great idea, Kay. I am also working on my cookbook, hopefully, you can watch out for it too!
I love to watch you cook it inspires me to want to do more recipes. I love your kitchen and you mentioned the dish soap you use and I just had to get some. It smells so good. I would like to know what meat thermometer you use?
Hi Jacque, thanks for always watching and checking out my recipes. Here are the thermometers that I use Instant-Read Thermometer and In-oven thermometer (roasts, turkey, etc):
At our house, a three bone rib serves 4 LOL. Love your recipes.
I’m so glad you’re loving our recipes, Matt! Merry Christmas!
Hi, love you videos. Years ago my mom made crumb cake. I’am 77, 2 days after Christmas. Do you possibly have a recipe for crumb cake. It has a kind of dense consistancy with a strusel top.Your video guy I think is your husband does a great job too. Merry Christmas.
Thank you for appreciating what my husband does. Here are some Crumb cake recipes that you can try.
NATASHA, LOVE ALL YOUR RECIPES EVERYTHING I HAVE MADE HAS BEEN GREAT. HAPPY HOLIDAYS TO YOU AND YOUR FAMILY . Annie
Annie
I’m happy to hear that you’ve been enjoying my recipes, Annie. Thank you for sharing and Happy Holidays!
I made your Prime Rib for Christmas Dinner. Absolutely the best I ever ate. Step by step trust me it was so easy the timing was perfect. I trusted your instructions to the minute. It was very expensive but worth every penny.
I’m so happy to hear you enjoyed this recipe! It is definitely a treat. Thank you for sharing your great review.
Just popping by to say a big Thank you for all your amazing recipes! Also, a very Merry Christmas from our home to yours. Stay safe, stay quirky, so many people love you Natasha. And a special note for your hubby who makes your videos amazing, I know how much work that is too!!! Love & warmth, Deliska
You’re so nice! Thank you, Deliska! I’m happy you’re enjoying our recipes & videos! Merry Christmas!
Hi Natasha love your cooking l have made quite a few of your recipes But need to know l’m making the chicken lasagna do I need to bake it before I freeze it or can I freeze it without baking?
Thank you, Aracelis. I’m glad that you’re enjoying my recipes. Yes, you can assemble it a day ahead and cook the following day, just be sure not to overcook the noodles.
Natasha I have a question I hope you can answer. I’ve been looking for years. Back in the 50’s there was a cut of roast that a long bone. It was shaped like a picnic ham only it was beef. Any idea’s?
Hello Sherry, it’s really hard to tell I’m sorry.
Hi Natasha, Sherry and others
I am a retired butcher in Australia, I have to say a prime rib roast h as to be the best beef roast you can have
I do have a condition and that is it needs to have some fat on it.
Sherry , it Is hard to answer your question but think now many restaurants offer a tomahawk steak, this is really a rib eye with with a longer bone.
I don’t ever remember selling these in Australia although they are popular now.
I love your cooking Natasha, you add so much fun to your recipes
Thank you so much for sharing that with us, Rob!
I believe you may be talking about the tomahawk cut.
My husband once ordered bone-in rib eye steak and it came on the plate looking like your description. It looked like a weapon. LOL
It’s called a cowboy steak
I think it was called an H Bone roast. I worked in a small market that sold a lot of meat and I remember a customer that asked for this cut often.
Thank you
It sounds like maybe they had the roast “frenched”. It’s where they cut the meat away from the bone so the appear to stick out.
Could you use orange instead of apricots for your ham glaze
Hi Monie, I haven’t tried that yet to advise. If you try it, please share with us how it goes.
Enjoy your blogs so much and the info you also give along with those delicious recipes! Thank you for your hard work and sharing your family with us. I really like how your daughter shows herself enjoying some of your recipes!
You’re welcome, Carolyn! Thank you for that thoughtful feedback. I’m so glad you’re enjoying our recipes.
Hi Natasha,
I have a 16 pound standing prime rib roast that I am making for Christmas dinner. I’ve never made one this large before. I’m not finding any information to tell me if I can make this whole or if I need to cut it into smaller portions before roasting it. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Thank you in advance and Merry Christmas! Sincerely, Rebecca O Houston, TX
Hi Rebecca, I would cut the roast in half and roast it as 2 pieces in a very large roasting pan that can accommodate both roasts together without touching. If your oven or roasting pan doesn’t accommodate both at the same time, you can roast in 2 separate ovens (if you have 2 ovens).
Sorry for my English, great information, I do not like to cook, but sense I found your Videos, I been enjoying some cooking, I did the prime rib last Christmas, was incredible, I didn’t select the ribs, but I want to select it this year, so what do you picked, 6 to 9 or 10 to 12, I’ll will love to know what do you cook.
I love your videos and you are so nice, sweet and fun, my husband said that you must be good, sense you make me wants to cook
Hi Pilar, that would depend on how many people you plan on serving this for.
I think she meant do you prefer the chuck end or loin end.
Oh got it, I like the loin end with a larger center eye of meat, but both are great.
Natasha, I came across your web site by accident and must say you are most impressive, funny, intelligent and very pretty. You really held my attention. Looking for tips on rib roast and there you were! Thank you!! Great job!!!
Thank you for that thoughtful & wonderful compliment! You’re so nice!
Thanks for posting this. Such great tips.
Hi Becky, I’m so glad you enjoyed the post!
This is excellent information; I can definitely use these tips for Christmas dinner this year!
I’m so glad you found it helpful. Thank you Sara! I hope you have a wonderful Christmas!
Natasha, you have done it again. I love the guide and all the details. It looks like a fancy cut of meat but now I know how to select the right cut.
I’m so glad you found this post helpful. The first time I went to the grocery store, I was a deer in the headlights. Having this knowledge would have given me more confidence for sure!
I love all the details on how to select prime rib! I think it will make it approachable for any home cook!
I’m so glad you found that helpful! Thank you for stopping by!